| Overall Grade: | B+ |
|---|---|
| Violence: | C+ |
| Sexual Content: | A- |
| Language: | A |
| Drugs/Alcohol: | A |
| Run Time: | 133 |
| MPAA Rating: | |
| Video Release: | 21 Mar 2005 |
In-Depth Review
ShareStar Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace is rated PG: for sci-fi action/violence.
What did the Y2K bug and The Phantom Menace have in common? The anticipation generated more excitement than their actual arrival enjoyed. Despite this, I'm sure the video and DVD releases of 'Menace' have caused many parents to be bugged by children pleading again for the associated licensed merchandise.
Categorized as a "prequel," meaning it begins prior to the first three films, this first episode introduces us to characters and a plot that will tangle and weave through two more movies until it becomes a perfect fit to the initial release back in the disco 70's. The fact that George Lucas has kept the "look" of this film so similar to those of 20 years ago is a feat in itself.
Meeting the youthful Obi-Wan Kenobi (Ewan McGregor) and Anakin Skywalker (Jake Lloyd--whose character, of course, will become the tyrant Darth Vader), is almost as fun as going back in time to discover your spouse in grade school. Skywalker and Kenobi, along with master Jedi trainer Qui-Gon Jinn (Liam Neeson) and a completely digitized character named Jar Jar Binks (voiced by Ahmed Best) become the team to root for. They attempt to save Queen Amidala (Natalie Portman) from a bad hair day, and her planet from being overrun by the Trade Federation.
Conflict is the core of any movie with "war" in its title, and The Phantom Menace is chock full of space-aged digital violence--but no gore. Thousands of those killed are robotic droids or lifeforms of non-human descent (that makes it okay?). With the exception of a high-speed "pod-race" (organized for recreational and gambling purposes, resulting in needless loss of life), the rest of the violence depicts individuals fighting for freedom after other attempts at negotiating have failed.
The lack of profanity and sex (other than a brief shot of a woman in just as brief a bikini) impressed me more than the effects, which is bound to make this film a huge hit with many families. The good news is, if the old Star Wars movies met your family's standards, this will too.
Studio: Twentieth Century Fox.
Was This Review Helpful?
If this review helped you find a great movie, or saved you time and money, please consider donating.
Content Details
Discussion Ideas
Is it more acceptable to kill non-humans (robots, aliens, etc.) than human beings?
This movie has been criticized for its simple, almost innocent story line. Yet it is very much like its predecessors. Is this a reflection on the evolution of the movie industry over the last 20 years?
Video alternatives
The other movies in the Star Wars franchise are:
Episode I: The Phantom Menace, Episode II: Attack of the Clones, Episode III: Revenge of the Sith and Episode IV: A New Hope, Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back, Episode VI: Return of the Jedi.
Interested in becoming a Jedi? We’ve reviewed three video games that put you in the driver’s seat, so to speak… Nintendo’s Star Wars: Episode 1 - Racer (where you get to try out one of those fancy podracers), along with Sony’s Star Wars: Episode 1 - The Phantom Menace for the Playstation (assume the identity of various characters by acting out scenes from the movie), and Star Wars Starfighter for the Playstation 2 (a single-player action adventure with a storyline that runs parallel to the movie).
Home Video Notes
DVD Release Information:
- Package type: Keep case
- Aspect ratio: Widescreen anamorphic - 2.35:1
- DVD encoding: Region 1
- Available audio tracks: English (Dolby Digital 5.1), English (Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround), Spanish (Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround).
- Available subtitles: English.
- THX Certified
- Commentary by George Lucas and numerous other crewmembers
- Deleted scenes documentary with 7 never before seen sequences completed for the DVD release
- One hour documentary culled from over 600 hours of footage
- Storyboard to animatic to film segment
- Five featurettes highlighting the storyline, design, costumes, visual effects, and fight sequences
- John Williams music video—Duel Of The Fates
- Production photo gallery
- International theatrical posters
- Theatrical teaser and launch trailers, seven TV spots
- Featurette: Making of the Sony Playstation 2 game by LucasArts—Star Wars Starfighter
With the entertainment world embracing the powerful DVD format over the past few years, there’s been a noticeable void in the thousands of DVD titles: Star Wars. With multiple releases of all four Star Wars episodes on VHS, it took until October 16, 2001, before the fabled space legend would find its way to the futuristic silver disc.
Following so much anticipation (shortly after the VHS release over a year ago, fans began petitions calling on George Lucas to deliver the disc), the market almost demands this to be one of the highest quality DVD releases to date… and it is.
A two-disc collection selling for a very reasonable $24, this DVD release is stuffed tighter than Queen Amidala’s hairdo.
Disc One contains completely animated chapter menus along with a commentary by Lucas and others that you can listen to while viewing the movie… the latter of which is also included. And compared to VHS quality, this DVD print is like seeing Episode 1 all over again. Finally, there are links to the Star Wars official web site, along with links especially for “DVD Owners.” (Unfortunately, we were unable to connect to the latter selection—perhaps due to our office’s computer firewall).
On Disc Two, fans will discover one of most informative “making of” documentaries put to DVD. Unlike so many others, which come across as cheap marketing hoopla, this is a true documentary that even forgoes the voiceover announcer. With honest remarks from creators beginning months before initial shooting begins, and working through the film’s four year production, this title could be worth the cost of the disc alone.
Other offerings on Disc Two include an interesting music video that is cut to a piece from the film’s dramatic score, a thorough explanation of “animatics” (the ability to rough out special effects in 3D animation) and how they assist the creative process—again samples are included from various parts of the film allowing you to see the application, a beautiful production photo gallery, theatrical posters of the movie from around the world, TV spots, and various promotional trailers. Only a short clip about Star Wars Starfighter—LucasArts’ Playstation 2 video game offering—comes across as more advertisement than information.
Toss in a half dozen more documentary featurettes dealing with everything from costumes to fight scenes, along with other short clips originally published on the Star Wars web site during the making of Episode 1, and you’ll find yourself sitting in your viewing pod for over six hours—and that’s if you don’t watch the movie.
Join the Conversation
About the Reviewer: Rod Gustafson
Rod Gustafson has worked in various media industries since 1977. He founded Parent Previews in 1993, and today continues to write and broadcast the reviews in newspapers, on radio and (of course) on the Internet. He currently serves as the President of the Alberta Association for Media Awareness, a provincial non-profit society. He also authors a regular column for The Parent's Television Council in Los Angeles. He and his wife Donna have four children.
